Nobody Wants This: Cast Guide for Season 3 - Netflix Tudum

  • Meet the Cast

    Nobody Wants This Cast: Kristen Bell and Adam Brody Welcome Fresh New Faces

    Sarah Silverman, Andrew Rannells, and show creator Erin Foster’s cameo shake up Season 3.  

    By Alex Frank
    Oct. 22, 2026

New season, new complications, new cast members. 

When we last caught up with the Nobody Wants This cast, everyone was headed into uncharted territory: Joanne (Kristen Bell) and her rabbi boyfriend, Noah (Adam Brody), were ready to take the next step in their relationship; Sasha (Timothy Simons) and his wife, Esther (Jackie Tohn), had separated; and Morgan (Justine Lupe) had called off an engagement and returned to the single life.

But if Season 2 left everyone at a crossroads, Season 3 is ready to pop the cork on loads of exciting developments. “This season feels like Champagne,” says executive producer and co-showrunner Jenni Konner.  

Season 3 picks up with Joanne and Noah already living together. But as Joanne works her way through the process of converting to Judaism, she’s introduced to a new social world that revolves around the temple. Enter: Sarah Silverman as Rabbi Eden, who leads Joanne’s conversion class, and Andrew Rannells as Sebastian, a fellow religion student with a biting tongue.

“Andrew is hysterical. He’s so malleable. He can give you exactly what you want. And Sarah plays sincere really, really well, and it’s a fun quality because it’s unexpected, and we really love getting to see that side of her,” says show creator Erin Foster, who herself shows up in a surprise cameo in Episode 4.  

Across LA, Esther continues her own journey of self-discovery, welcoming a new man, Julian (Steven Weber), into her life. Sasha’s attempts at bachelorhood are a little shakier. At the same time, Morgan is charting her own path — trying to create (and predict, with the help of a psychic played by Sadie Sandler) a future for herself that involves book publishing and better luck with relationships. 

Below, check in with the Angelenos at the heart of Nobody Wants This — including new faces, old friends, and a couple of buzzy cameos — and stream Season 3 now, exclusively on Netflix. 

The couple 

 

Woman in leopard print jacket sitting at a table, smiling and talking with others, two glasses of champagne in front of her, modern indoor setting with blurred background and plants.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Kristen Bell

as Joanne
About the Character

Joanne is the outspoken podcast host who fell in love with a rabbi named Noah. She and Noah have taken the next step in their relationship and moved in together. After navigating the prospect of conversion throughout Season 2, Joanne has decided to take the leap and join the Jewish faith in Season 3. 

 

Joanne is striving to figure out what it means not just to become Jewish, but to build a life with a rabbi on her own terms. “It’s a hurdle, but it’s representative of these two people coming from different worlds and coming together and trying to make it work,” says Foster, who based the show on her own real-life love story. 

Previously In

The Good Place, Veronica Mars, Frozen

Watch on Netflix
The Woman in the House Across the Street from the Girl in the Window
Watch
Follow Kristen Bell

Man wearing suit and tallit standing at a podium with a microphone, speaking in a synagogue or religious setting with wood paneling and soft lighting in the background.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Adam Brody

as Noah
About the Character

Noah is the unconventional rabbi who only has eyes for Joanne. Now that Noah and Joanne have moved in together and are fully committed, Noah is striving to reclaim his place front and center at Temple Chai.

 

Meanwhile, on the home front, Noah is trying to be a good partner during an entirely new phase in the couple’s bond — while also navigating exciting new milestones. “They’re still these very different people making a life together. And while there’s no kind of crisis in the relationship this season, they’re still trying to figure out how to make a life together because they approach things differently,” says Foster. “There’s still a learning curve.”

Previously In

The O.C., Jennifer’s Body, Ready or Not

Watch on Netflix
My Father's Dragon
Watch

The family and friends 

Woman in a shiny silver sequin dress posing confidently in a stylish living room with books, decor items, and warm lighting on wooden shelves and cabinets in the background.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Justine Lupe

as Morgan
About the Character

It’s a season of growth for Morgan, Joanne’s sister and co-host of their Nobody Wants This podcast. At the end of Season 2, she’d broken off an engagement, and now, with her sister firmly ensconced in a relationship of her own, it’s time for Morgan to find her place. In Season 3, she navigates the prospect of becoming a thought leader and possible author. 

 

“It feels right that Morgan, at this juncture in her life, would be like, ‘OK, how can I become something bigger than I am?’” says EP and co-showrunner Bruce Eric Kaplan.

 

As Morgan’s career is on the rise, her romantic life enters a complicated zone. In Season 3, she’s forced to question what her connection with Sasha — who she’s long had chemistry with — really is. 

Previously In

Succession, Mr. Mercedes, The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel

Watch on Netflix
Luckiest Girl Alive
Watch
Follow Justine Lupe

A man stands in a warmly lit living room holding a colorful umbrella with a pink handle, wearing a patterned jacket and light blue hoodie, near a brown couch and cardboard boxes, with a window showing trees outside at night.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Timothy Simons

as Sasha
About the Character

Sasha is Noah’s older brother. And now that his wife, Esther, has asked for a separation after years of marriage, Sasha is starting to ask — for the first time in a while — what he wants out of life. 

 

“Sasha really doesn’t want to go out there,” says Foster. “But then he starts to gain momentum and starts to have fun experiences and realizes there’s more out there.”

Previously In

Veep, The Handmaid’s Tale, Don’t Worry Darling

Watch on Netflix
The Twits
Watch
Gold
Watch
Irreplaceable You
Watch
Follow Timothy Simons

Smiling woman holding a woven basket opens a wooden door inside a warmly lit home, with a framed painting and light switches visible on the wall.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Jackie Tohn

as Esther
About the Character

Esther asked Sasha for a separation in Season 2 so that she could go on a journey of self-discovery — and that’s exactly what she does in Season 3. She finds an exciting new connection with the wealthy Julian. But she also deals with her own insecurities and foibles as a newly single mom. 

 

“Esther starts out so excited about the possibilities,” says Foster. “[But] it’s hard to be a mom in her 40s on a dating app. It’s like, ‘Wait a second, there’s not all these amazing guys better than my husband out there waiting for me.’ It doesn’t feel good.” 

 

Julian may just be the antidote to the Tinder blues. 

Previously In

GLOW, Best Leftovers Ever!, A Futile and Stupid Gesture

Watch on Netflix
Best Leftovers Ever!
Watch
GLOW
Watch
A Futile and Stupid Gesture
Watch
Follow Jackie Tohn

Man in a purple sweater sitting at a table in a warmly lit indoor setting, looking engaged in conversation, with a wine glass and another person partially visible nearby.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Michael Hitchcock

as Henry
About the Character

Henry is Joanne and Morgan’s kooky dad, who has embarked on his own post-divorce dating journey. So when Sasha finds himself newly single, Henry is more than happy to offer some unconventional — and questionable — advice for navigating bachelorhood.

Previously In

Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, EXmas

Watch on Netflix
Mascots
Watch
Follow Michael Hitchcock

Woman in glasses and white blouse sitting indoors at a table with a drink, flowers in the background, warm lighting, casual atmosphere.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Stephanie Faracy

as Lynn
About the Character

Lynn is Joanne and Morgan’s supportive — if slightly capricious — mom. She’s a “weird, weird witch of a mom,” as Morgan lovingly phrases it. This season, Lynn takes particular interest in Sasha and Morgan’s evolving relationship.

Previously In

Uncoupled, Mike and Dave Need Wedding Dates


Smiling bald man in dark clothes stands in the doorway of a warmly lit home, holding the door open with one hand and a handbag over his arm, interior room with shelves visible in the background.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Paul Ben-Victor

as Ilan
About the Character

Ilan is Noah and Sasha’s dad. He loves his wife and his family — and does his best to support Sasha on his new journey as a bachelor. 

Previously In

The Wire, The Irishman

Watch on Netflix
Monster
Watch
The Irishman
Watch
Follow Paul Ben-Victor

Older woman in a vintage floral blouse smiles, standing on a staircase indoors, hands on wall and railing, warmly engaging with people in a cozy home setting.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Tovah Feldshuh

as Bina
About the Character

Bina is the loving — if intimidating — Roklov matriarch. She’s Noah’s mother, and Joanne has always wanted to impress her. Bina has always seemed skeptical of Joanne’s place in the Roklov family. But things start to change in Season 3. As Joanne begins her conversion to Judaism, she starts to wonder whether Bina represents the traditional rebbetzin she should aspire to be. Bina even gives Joanne a makeover to help her appear ready to be a rabbi’s wife. But Joanne ultimately realizes that the best version of herself is simply herself.

Previously In

Kissing Jessica Stein, Crazy Ex-Girlfriend

Follow Tovah Feldshuh

Woman with long black hair stands indoors with hands on hips, wearing a maroon top in a cozy, well-lit room with framed photos and bright curtains, giving an expression of concern or contemplation.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Sherry Cola

as Ashley
About the Character

Ashley produces Joanne and Morgan’s Nobody Wants This podcast. We also have her to thank for bringing Joanne and Noah together — they meet at her dinner party in the first episode of the series premiere. And this season, Ashley takes on the role of Morgan’s manager, trying to secure her a book deal for her viral advice. 

Previously In

Good Trouble, Joy Ride

Watch on Netflix
That '90s Show
Watch
Follow Sherry Cola

The newbies 

Woman with dark hair in a bun, wearing a patterned dress and cream cardigan, sits at a wooden table in an office, gesturing as she speaks, with certificates and a blue book visible on a shelf behind her.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Sarah Silverman

as Rabbi Eden
About the Character

As the teacher for an Intro to Judaism class at the temple, Rabbi Eden is a comforting — if sometimes comically critical — voice in Joanne’s big transition to the Jewish faith.  

Previously In

School of Rock, Wreck-It Ralph

Watch on Netflix
Sarah Silverman A Speck of Dust
Watch
Sarah Silverman: PostMortem
Watch
Maestro
Watch
Follow Sarah Silverman

Man in sunglasses and yellow shorts sits by a pool talking to a woman on a float at an outdoor pool party, with other casually dressed people socializing in the background surrounded by greenery and sunlight.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Andrew Rannells

as Sebastien
About the Character

Joanne’s nemesis in the Intro to Judaism class, Sebastien plants seeds of insecurity in Joanne about the future of her relationship. Still, these two simply cannot stop hanging out. 

Previously In

Girls, Book of Mormon, Too Much

Watch on Netflix
The Boys in the Band
Watch
Too Much
Watch
Black Monday
Watch
Follow Andrew Rannells

Woman with blonde hair in space buns, wearing a denim jacket with faux fur collar and hoop earrings, sitting indoors at a table in a softly lit environment, with blurred background suggesting a casual public setting.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Erin Foster

as Nicole
About the Character

Surprise! It’s a cameo role from the show creator herself. She plays a chaotically messy fan of Joanne’s podcast who almost derails Noah’s big romantic gesture. 

Previously In

The O.C., Barely Famous

Follow Erin Foster

Smiling older man with gray hair and beard in a brown jacket sits at a dimly lit restaurant table with wine glasses, blurred city lights in background, creating a warm, relaxed atmosphere.

Steven Weber

as Julian
About the Character

A wealthy divorced Angeleno, Julian is a new prospect for Esther, who’s exploring what it means to be single after her separation from Sasha. 

Previously In

Wings, Chicago Med

Watch on Netflix
Social Distance
Watch
The Perfection
Watch
13 Reasons Why
Watch
Follow Steven Weber

Smiling woman in a cozy sweater sits at a conference table with a notebook and pen, a yellow coffee cup nearby, and bookshelves in the background, suggesting a meeting or discussion in an office or library setting.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Keyla Monterroso Mejia

as Amber 
About the Character

A fellow student in Joanne’s conversion class, Amber makes it known right away that she’s eager to find a Jewish husband of her own. 

Previously In

The Studio, Abbott Elementary

Watch on Netflix
On My Block
Watch
Follow Keyla Monterroso Mejia

Man in a dark sweater holding a phone stands outdoors in a suburban neighborhood with trees, bushes, and a parked car in the background.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Avan Jogia

as Travis
About the Character

Joanne’s hard-to-impress former boyfriend, Travis moves next door — and quickly becomes a thorn in the side of both Joanne and Noah.

Previously In

56 Days, Our Hero, Balthazar

Watch on Netflix
Victorious
Watch
Follow Avan Jogia

A woman with long brown hair sits at a bar, smiling and talking to a man in a hat. The background shows bottles, a bartender, and warm lighting, creating a cozy atmosphere.

Stephanie Koenig

as Poppy
About the Character

Poppy is Sasha’s dating app match, and she isn’t quite sure they’re really a match. Poppy also isn’t too shy to let him know.

Previously In

English Teacher, Lessons in Chemistry 

Watch on Netflix
Running Point
Watch
Follow Stephanie Koenig

Young woman with long dark hair sits at a table with tarot cards, crystals, and a mug in a warmly lit, cozy room decorated with paintings, books, and vintage furniture, suggesting a mystical, relaxed atmosphere.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Sadie Sandler

as Denise
About the Character

A young psychic who gives Morgan a reading that Morgan promptly interprets however she wants — particularly as it pertains to her dream of becoming a bestselling writer. But Denise’s reading may ultimately have more to do with Morgan’s heart than her mind. 

Previously In

Roommates

Watch on Netflix
Roommates
Watch
You Are So Not Invited to My Bat Mitzvah
Watch
Follow Sadie Sandler

Woman with straight dark hair and a bold gold necklace sitting indoors, wearing a white blouse, looking to the side with a slight smile; blurred cityscape and buildings visible through a window in the background.

Poorna Jagannathan

as Eleanor
About the Character

The martini-swilling publisher aunt of Sebastien meets with Morgan to discuss her idea for a book, only to be thoroughly unimpressed with Morgan’s lackadaisical approach. Eleanor used to work with Joyce Carol Oates, after all!

Previously In

Deli Boys, Lanterns

Watch on Netflix
Never Have I Ever
Watch
The Out-Laws
Watch
Follow Poorna Jagannathan

Middle-aged man with gray hair and beard wearing an orange shirt stands outdoors, smiling and looking to the side, with leafy green trees and a bright, natural background behind him.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

Philip Rosenthal

as Cousin Irv
About the Character

The iconic sitcom creator and LA restaurateur makes a cameo as Noah’s cousin, whose unexpected appearance prompts Noah to rethink the wedding guest list. And foodie Angelenos with a sharp eye will spot a special little Rosenthal-related Easter egg: Noah and Joanne visit Rosenthal’s real-life restaurant, Max and Helen’s, earlier in the season.

Previously In

Somebody Feed Phil, Curb Your Enthusiasm, BoJack Horseman

Watch on Netflix
Somebody Feed Phil
Watch
BoJack Horseman
Watch
Follow Philip Rosenthal

 

More on Nobody Wants This

Shop Nobody Wants This

Meet the Cast

Romance

Related Videos

Popular Now

Popular Releases