Is 'Lost Girls' Based on a True Story - Netflix Tudum

  • Deep Dive

    ‘Lost Girls’ and the Gilgo Beach Serial Killings. What to Know About the Movie

    Academy Award nominee Amy Ryan stars as a mother searching for her missing daughter, a suspected LISK victim.

    By Ingrid Ostby
    March 5, 2024

After her daughter goes missing, one woman’s relentless efforts to find her child uncover a wave of unsolved murders on Long Island. Based on real events about a purported serial killer and the woman who set out to find his victims, the 2020 film Lost Girls is the narrative feature debut of Emmy winner and Academy Award-nominated documentary filmmaker Liz Garbus (The Fourth EstateWhat Happened, Miss Simone?). 

Popular Now

  • The Gentlemen Season 2 Cast: Meet Eddie’s Growing Empire of Allies and Enemies
    Three stylish people stand on a grand stone balcony in front of an elegant building at dusk, with a tiger at the bottom of the image, creating a dramatic and luxurious atmosphere.

When will Lost Girls be released?

Stream it now.

Where can I find the trailer for Lost Girls?

Check it out below.

Who’s in Lost Girls?

  • Amy Ryan (Beau Is Afraid, Only Murders in the Building) as Mari, Shannan’s mom
  • Thomasin McKenzie (Last Night in Soho, Jojo Rabbit) as Sherre, Mari’s middle child
  • Oona Laurence (The Beguiled, Southpaw) as Sarra Gilbert, Mari’s youngest daughter
  • Gabriel Byrne (War of the Worlds, Maniac) as Long Island Police Commissioner Richard Dormer
  • Lola Kirke (Winning Time: The Rise of the Lakers Dynasty) as Kim, the sister of a missing woman named Amber

What happens in Lost Girls?

After a 24-year-old sex worker named Shannan mysteriously disappears one night, her mother, Mari, is determined to find her at all costs. So when the police fail to make Shannan’s disappearance a priority, Mari takes matters into her own hands — driving an investigation within an insular gated community near Long Island’s outer banks. In doing so, Mari’s efforts enable detectives to uncover numerous unsolved murders. 

Is Lost Girls based on a book?

Yes. It’s based on the nonfiction book Lost Girls: An Unsolved American Mystery by Robert Kolker. 

Oona Laurence, Amy Ryan, Thomasin McKenzie and Miriam Shor in ‘Lost Girls’

Oona Laurence, Amy Ryan, Thomasin McKenzie and Miriam Shor in Lost Girls

Jessica Kourkounis/Netflix

Is Lost Girls based on a true story?

Yes. Lost Girls is inspired by the true story of Shannan Gilbert’s disappearance, her mother Mari Gilbert’s efforts to find her, and the Long Island serial killer — or LISK, as he has become known — who is alleged to have killed up to 18 people between the years 1996 and 2011. 

Was the killer in Lost Girls ever found? 

A suspect was arrested and charged in three of the murders in July 2023. 

Where does Lost Girls take place?

Lost Girls takes place on the South Shore of Long Island, New York.

Go Behind the Streams with TudumWith breaking news, exclusive sneak peeks, interviews and more, Tudum helps you dive deeper into the stories you love.
Related Tags
  • Drama
  • Deep Dive
  • Article

Shop Lost Girls

Go to Netflix Shop

Deep Dive

  • Love Is Blind: UK Season 3: Everything You Need to Know
    Cheers, babes! Love Is Blind has returned to the UK for more cheeky pod chats. 
  • Get ready to get real with the social media phenom and her family.
  • “How much of himself does Eddie lose whilst getting revenge?” Theo James asks.
  • From bespoke suits and Italian boats to the perfect hunting pants, the cast and creators reveal the rules of living dangerously well.
  • Are you ready to step back into a world of pure imagination this fall?
  • Director James Ashcroft and author Alex North discuss adapting the book.

Drama

  • These selections will have you reminiscing about trips to the video store.
  • Plus Crew Girl, Call My Agent! The Movie, DANG!, The Perfect Lie, and more.
  • Set in the world of The Secret of Secrets, the show stars Morgan Spector and Rebecca Hall. 
  • Directed by Cord Jefferson, Meryl Streep will star in the enduring story of family dysfunction and American anxiety.
  • The police procedural stars Mary McDonnell, G.W. Bailey, and Tony Denison.
  • The acclaimed LGBTQ+ epic will arrive on Netflix later this year.
  • Eddie and Susie are taking their criminal enterprise to Italy in September.