Stolen Baby: The True Story of Heidi Broussard and Magen Fieramusca - Netflix Tudum

  • What To Watch

    Stolen Baby: What Happened to Heidi Broussard? Here’s the True Story

    The crime drama is based on the real-life case involving Magen Fieramusca.

    By Krutika Mallikarjuna
    May 15, 2026

When Heidi Broussard (Anna Hopkins), a sweet, churchgoing woman from Austin, tells her long-distance best friend Magen Fieramusca (Emily Osment) that she’s expecting again, she’s delighted to hear that Magen’s also pregnant, with her first baby. The two friends embark on their pregnancy journeys together, sharing updates and pics of their growing bellies. Magen’s so supportive that she even drives from Houston to Austin to be with Heidi when Heidi gives birth. But two weeks after Heidi’s baby is born, things take a dark turn. Both mother and newborn disappear, kicking off a nationwide search. Police investigate Heidi’s last known whereabouts, and when a neighbor tells them that Heidi got into Magen’s car on the day of her disappearance, detectives grow suspicious of Magen. What they uncover is a sinister plot beyond their wildest imaginations. Directed by Michelle Ouellet (The True Heroines), the drama film Stolen Baby: The Murder of Heidi Broussard is based on a real 2019 murder case.

Popular Now

  • News
    KPop Demon Hunters Global Concert Tour Is Coming — Sign Up for Tickets Now
    May 13
    Three animated female performers stand on a lit stage facing a cheering crowd under the text "K-Pop Demon Hunters World Tour" during a night concert event.

Who’s in the cast of Stolen Baby?

  • Emily Osment (The Kominsky Method) as Magen Fieramusca
  • Anna Hopkins (The Expanse) as Heidi Broussard
  • Ian Lake (Star Trek: Discovery) as Cody
  • Jamie Spilchuk (Suits) as Greg
  • Sabryn Rock (Two Sentence Horror Stories) as Sarah
  • Candice Lidstone (Laughing All the Way) as Leighanne
  • Paulino Nunes (Slasher) as FBI Agent Paul Richards
  • Sonia Dhillon Tully (Wedding Season) as Detective Bonnie Majors
  • Ashton Cressman (Violent Night 2) as Aiden
  • Jolanta Mojsej (The Truth About Christmas) as Crystal

What’s the true story behind Stolen Baby?

Stolen Baby is based on the 2019 murder case of Heidi Broussard. On Dec. 12, 2019, Heidi, along with her 2-week-old newborn, Margot, disappeared after dropping her eldest child off at school. After a weeklong search, investigators discovered Heidi’s body in the trunk of Magen’s car, and found that Heidi had been strangled to death. Police arrested Magen, who had faked her pregnancy with the intention of stealing Margot and passing the child off as her own. Authorities found Heidi’s baby alive and well inside Magen’s Houston home, and promptly returned her to her family. Magen was charged with two counts of kidnapping and one count of tampering with a corpse, then later with capital murder. She pleaded guilty to murder, having strangled Heidi to death, and is currently serving a sentence of 55 years in prison on a reduced charge of first-degree murder.

Gripping True Crime Documentaries to Stream NowFrom ‘Murdaugh Murders’ to ‘The Tinder Swindler,’ dive into these true stories.

Shop Stolen Baby: The Murder of Heidi Broussard

GO TO NETFLIX SHOP

Discover More What To Watch

  • What To Watch
    Hoax: What Happened to Sherri Papini? Here’s the True Story
    A mom tells police she survived a kidnapping, but the truth is much darker. 
    By Krutika Mallikarjuna
    7:00 am
  • What To Watch
    There’s a new kingpin in Karachi.
    By Krutika Mallikarjuna
    7:00 am
  • What To Watch
    The Stranger Things actor joins NBA and WNBA champs to voice the sports comedy.
    By Ingrid Ostby
    Yesterday 4:55 pm
  • What To Watch
    From Nemesis to The Rip.
    By Anne Cohen
    Yesterday 1:00 pm
  • What To Watch
    They’re arrestingly good.
    By Allison Picurro
    Yesterday 1:00 pm
  • What To Watch
    Nothing satisfies like karma.
    By Ananda Dillon
    May 13
  • What To Watch
    They’re out of this world.
    By Allison Picurro
    May 12
  • What To Watch
    Join the inner circle of supreme streamers.
    By Ananda Dillon
    May 12

Discover More True Crime

  • Status Update
    The documentary filmmakers share what it took for Shirilla to break her silence.
    By Tudum Staff
    7:00 am
  • News
    A horrible crash left behind two lost lives, one survivor, and many questions.
    By Tudum Staff
    7:00 am
  • Recommendations
    Delve into stories about unforgettable victims, mysteries, and twisted minds.
    By Tudum Staff
    7:00 am
  • Deep Dive
    The series features interviews with Becky Hill and witnesses from the 2023 trial. 
    Ingrid Ostby & Troy Pozirekides
    Yesterday 11:32 pm
  • Deep Dive
    Is one powerful family to blame for the deaths of five people in the wilds of South Carolina’s Lowcountry?
    By Ingrid Ostby
    Yesterday 11:28 pm