The American Gladiators Unauthorized Documentary 'Muscles & Mayhem' Is a Brawl from Beginning to End - Netflix Tudum

  • Deep Dive

    The Unauthorized American Gladiators Doc ‘Muscles & Mayhem’ Is an All-Out Brawl 

    The ’90s TV show became a pop culture phenomenon — before it devolved into chaos.

    By Ingrid Ostby
    June 22, 2023

In the late ’80s and early ’90s, muscly hunks and bodybuilding were all the rage. We had Arnold, we had Stallone, we had ThunderCats, we had WWF’s Prime Time Wrestling… and we had American Gladiators. If you’re too young to know or too old to remember, the show featured a bunch of coed superjocks who took on average joes in various physical challenges — like jousting each other with pugil sticks atop raised circular platforms or assaulting each other with weapons full of ammo (well, orange tennis balls). It was campy, it was fun and the gladiators lived like rock stars… until it all went down in flames. 

Directed by Jared Hess (Napoleon DynamiteMurder Among the Mormons) and Emmy winner Tony Vainuku (Independent Lens: In Football We Trust), Muscles & Mayhem: An Unauthorized Story of American Gladiators looks back at the phenomenon that was American Gladiators, the athletes who became overnight sensations and the drama that led to its bittersweet end. 

1 / 9
American Gladiators star Lori “Ice” Fetrick shows off her uniform from the show, along with an Ice trading card and action figure. “These items were the beginning of my new life” she says. Fetrick now hosts a podcast and has a T-shirt line.
Since American Gladiators came to an end, Danny Lee “Nitro” Clark has authored two books, given a TED Talk and created a nationwide obstacle adventure run.
Clark snapped a pic of some of his American Gladiator memorabilia.
Raye “Zap” Hollitt wears her Jeff Hamilton jacket. “[Nitro, Laser, Tower, Ice and I] wore them throughout the tour that we did.” These days, Hollitt is a trainer in South Lake Tahoe, California, where she teaches snowboarding and works in a casino.
Jim “Laser” Kalafat (Starr) reflects on his American Gladiator tour jacket, pictured here. “[It] was custom-made and is very special to me.”
Kalafat wore the jacket on tour back in the day, to sign autographs and while filming the recent Netflix documentary.
Steve “Tower” Henneberry in a recent photo wearing his gladiator jacket. “Thirty years later and it still fits,” Henneberry says.
Clark stands proudly by a T-shirt with his likeness from the Gladiator days.
Kalafat works his arm muscles at the gym. Since the show’s end, he’s served as an executive for a number of companies, and now runs two businesses.

When will Muscles & Mayhem: An Unauthorized Story of American Gladiators be released?

Stream it now on Netflix.

Who’s in Muscles & Mayhem: An Unauthorized Story of American Gladiators?

  • Danny Lee “Nitro” Clark
  • Debbie “Storm” Clark
  • Erika “Diamond” Andersch
  • Jim “Laser” Kalafat (Starr)
  • Lori “Ice” Fetrick
  • Michael “Gemini” Horton
  • Raye “Zap” Hollitt
  • Sha-Ri “Blaze” Pendleton-Mitchell 
  • Sky Eson-Korito
  • Steve “Tower” Henneberry
  • Lisa McCullough, the original Zap

Muscles & Mayhem: An Unauthorized Story of American Gladiators also includes footage of former gladiators Marisa “Lace” Pare, Cheryl “Sunny” Baldinger, Deron Michael “Sunny” McBee and more. 

What happens in Muscles & Mayhem: An Unauthorized Story of American Gladiators?

The series gives a behind-the-scenes look at American Gladiators — how it started, its biggest stars and all the chaos that marked its nearly decade-long run. Airing from 1989 to 1996, American Gladiators was the first of its kind — where everyday people from across the US engaged in physical competition against hulking professionals known as gladiators. Eventually, the series became the No. 1 syndicated program in the world. But as its popularity grew, so did the gladiators’ egos — and their resentment about how they were treated by the network. Muscles & Mayhem: An Unauthorized Story of American Gladiators captures the rise and fall of the hit game show. 

Shop Muscles & Mayhem: An Unauthorized Story of American Gladiators

GO TO NETFLIX SHOP

Discover More Deep Dive

  • Deep Dive
    My Royal Nemesis: Everything to Know About the Time-Traveling K-Drama
    A consort from the Joseon era finds a connection with a modern-day businessman.
    By Krutika Mallikarjuna
    May 8
  • Deep Dive
    Find out the connection between Tova, Cameron, and an octopus named Marcellus.
    By Jean Bentley
    May 8
  • Deep Dive
    Answer: It’s back, funnier than ever. Question: What is Pop Culture Jeopardy!
    By Melanie Whyte
    May 7
  • Deep Dive
    Money Heist’s Pedro Alonso and his crew are coming back for the new installment.
    By Jean Bentley & Ingrid Ostby
    May 7
  • Deep Dive
    A family is split between two worlds in this three-season series.
    By Krutika Mallikarjuna
    May 7
  • Deep Dive
    The Nordic crime thriller returns with a killer playing a lethal game.
    By Krutika Mallikarjuna
    May 7
  • Deep Dive
    There are layers to this sharp-tongued, charismatic beauty.
    By Alex Frank
    May 6
  • Deep Dive
    When Caroline found out Sandy’s darkest secret, she stayed by his side.
    By Krutika Mallikarjuna
    May 6

Discover More Documentary

  • Preview
    The actor-comedian is getting the roast treatment at Netflix is a Joke Fest.
    By Ashley Lee
    Yesterday 1:00 pm
  • New on Netflix
    Plus The Roast of Kevin Hart, Pop Culture Jeopardy!, Perfect Match, and more.
    By Ashley Lee
    May 8
  • What To Watch
    Now if only we all had eight tentacles like Marcellus for snacking.
    By Ananda Dillon
    May 8
  • What To Watch
    The legendary naturalist turns 100 years old.
    By Caitlin Busch
    May 8
  • What To Watch
    She’s sure to love them (almost as much as she loves you).
    By Allie Baker
    May 6
  • News
    Plus: Man on Fire blazes to the top, and Swapped brings colorful family fun.
    By Ananda Dillon and Ashley Lee
    May 5
  • News
    A new three-part docuseries explores Kylie Minogue’s illustrious career.
    By Tudum Staff
    May 5

Latest News

  • Behind the Scenes
    Gina Carano Finally Gets to Fight Back
    1:00 pm
    Gina Carano with braided hair in athletic wear sits with arms crossed in an MMA gym, "Syndicate MMA" visible on the wall behind her, suggesting a focused training environment.

Popular Now

  • News
    Sally Field stars in the film, which is now streaming.
    By Brookie McIlvaine
    May 8
  • New on Netflix
    Stream Remarkably Bright Creatures, Swapped, Lord of the Flies, and more.
    By Ashley Lee
    April 30
  • News
    Make room on your bookshelf for a two-volume graphic novel adaptation.
    By Stephan Lee
    May 5