Who Is Erin Foster Playing in Nobody Wants This? Andrew Rannells, Sarah Silverman New Characters Explained - Netflix Tudum

  • News

    Meet the New Cast Members Joining Nobody Wants This Season 3

    Andrew Rannells, Keyla Monterroso Mejia, Sarah Silverman, and creator Erin Foster join the rom-com.

    Sept. 10, 2026

Noah (Adam Brody) and Joanne’s (Kristen Bell) love story just got a lot bigger. The latest photos of Nobody Wants This have arrived, and they’re giving us a sneak peek at some of the new cast members joining Season 3. 

You’ll spot Andrew Rannells, Keyla Monterroso Mejia, and Sarah Silverman — along with creator and executive producer Erin Foster, who is making her debut in front of the Nobody Wants This camera in a cameo appearance. Foster will be playing a mysterious character named Nicole when Season 3 premieres on Oct. 22.   

“Nicole really represents this sort of single, scatterbrained, crazy version that Joanne used to see herself as,” Foster explains. You’ll have to tune in to see what happens when newly matured Joanne is confronted with a “self-destructive and self-sabotaging” version of her past self.

A woman in a denim jacket with a fur collar gestures while talking to two people at an indoor airport terminal, with signs and passengers visible in the background.

After all, the Joanne of Season 3 is very different from the woman fans met at the start of Nobody Wants This. The new season picks up as Joanne and Noah are moving into a home — and a relationship — that finally feels solid, embracing every exciting "first" that comes with building their life together.

Across Los Angeles, Sasha (Timothy Simons) and Esther (Jackie Tohn) are thrust back into the dating world, whether they like it or not, stumbling through all the awkwardness (and unexpected thrill) of getting to know someone new, right as Morgan (Justine Lupe) takes her career to the next level, on her way to becoming an (almost) media sensation. Meanwhile, Sasha and Morgan have been circling something neither of them has been able to admit to.

Man in sunglasses and yellow shorts sits by a pool talking to a woman on a float at an outdoor pool party, with other casually dressed people socializing in the background surrounded by greenery and sunlight.
PHOTO BY KATRINA MARCHINOWSKI

So how do the new characters of Season 3 factor into the next chapter of Nobody Wants This? And who else can you expect to see? Below, discover all the new cast members and the roles they’ll play as Noah and Joanne’s love story continues. 

  • Andrew Rannells as Sebastien, Joanne’s nemesis in conversion class.
  • Keyla Monterroso Mejia as Amber, a single woman enrolled in Joanne’s Intro to Judaism class who is obsessed with finding a Jewish husband.
  • Sarah Silverman as Rabbi Eden, the warm, quirky teacher of an Intro to Judaism class, and a supportive presence for Joanne and Noah.
  • Avan Jogia as Travis, a confident and unbothered guys’ guy who enjoys getting under Joanne’s skin.
  • Erin Foster as Nicole, a terminally single, chaotic, and somewhat messy person ... She’s Joanne if everything had gone wrong in her life.
  • Poorna Jagannathan as Eleanor, Sebastien’s brassy and biting aunt.
  • Sadie Sandler as Denise, a young psychic who gives a reading to Morgan.
  • Stephanie Koenig as Poppy, an incredibly upbeat woman who goes on a date with Sasha.
  • Steven Weber as Julian, a funny, grounded, cool, and secure divorced dad.

Keep coming back to Tudum for more updates on what’s next for Noah, Joanne, and all their loved ones. And tune in when Nobody Wants This Season 3 premieres on Oct. 22, only on Netflix.

Is Nobody Wants This Based on a True Story?
Source Photos (L-R): Maya Dehlin Spach/WireImage/Getty Images, Rob Latour/Shutterstock, Jason Armond/Los Angeles Times/Getty Images

More on Nobody Wants This

Shop Nobody Wants This

News

Comedy

Related Videos

Popular Now

Popular Releases